WoW Forever Priest · Spec & class choice

Shadow Priest or Warlock in WoW Forever?

Ryan Geldun 18:53 video
Short answer

Shadow Priest or Warlock in World of Warcraft: Forever (WoW Forever)? If you want group content, dungeons and short queues, play a Shadow Priest. If you want the biggest damage, stronger crowd control and demons, play a Warlock. In this video Ryan Geldun compares both at level 34 in WoW Forever, after playing Warlock through WoW Classic (2019) and TBC and testing a Warlock in Forever up to level 15. Recorded in November 2026.

WATCH
Watch on YouTube Full Priest playlist All WoW Forever Priest guides

Quick facts

GameWorld of Warcraft: Forever (WoW Forever)
ComparisonShadow Priest vs Warlock (Affliction, Destruction, Demonology)
Shadow Priest winsversatility, self-healing, dungeon queues (can queue as healer), less gear competition
Warlock winscrowd control (Fear, Succubus Seduction), raw damage, demon pets
About equalquesting speed, gold farming, PvP pressure
ExecutesShadow Word: Death (all Priest specs) vs Shadowburn (Warlock)
Recorded atlevel 34, November 2026

Key takeaways

  • Rotation: a Shadow Priest plays a lot like an Affliction Warlock in WoW Forever. Shadow Word: Pain works like Corruption and Devouring Plague like Curse of Agony.
  • Versatility goes to the Priest. Shadow keeps Renew, Heal, Power Word: Shield and Spirit Tap, so a Shadow Priest can solo hard content and heal itself all day. Warlock utility (summons, Healthstones, Soulstones) mostly helps other people.
  • Crowd control goes to the Warlock: spammable Fear plus Succubus Seduction on humanoids.
  • Executes: every Priest spec gets Shadow Word: Death in WoW Forever; Warlocks get Shadowburn.
  • Gold: both classes farm gold well. Professions and the farming spot matter more than the class. Dotting and skinning coastal turtles is a good early gold farm.
  • Dungeons are a big Priest advantage. The Looking for Group tool is full of DPS, and a Shadow Priest can queue as a healer. A Warlock can't.
  • Questing speed is about the same. Spirit Tap means Priests rarely sit for mana; Warlocks use Life Tap but sometimes have to eat.
  • Far more people play Warlock in WoW Forever, so expect more competition for loot.
  • Demonology pets are a unique extra for Warlock, but managing demons well is a skill of its own.
  • PvP: both are strong. Shadow Priest has a slight edge in battlegrounds (Shadow Word: Death crits, shields for teammates); a good Affliction Warlock puts huge pressure on healers.
  • Raids: too early to tell. WoW Forever changed raid mechanics, removed debuff limits and reworked curses.

Chapters

  1. 0:00Shadow Priest or Warlock?
  2. 0:33What to compare: solo, elites, gold, PvP
  3. 1:18Rotation: Shadow Priest vs Affliction Warlock
  4. 2:50Versatility and self-healing
  5. 4:39Destruction Warlock and Shadow Bolt
  6. 5:31Executes: Shadowburn vs Shadow Word: Death
  7. 5:44Making gold
  8. 6:25Dungeons and finding a group
  9. 8:58Questing speed and mana
  10. 10:29First 100 gold and skinning turtles
  11. 11:39Gear competition
  12. 12:23Demonology and pets
  13. 14:31PvP and battlegrounds
  14. 17:02Verdict: which class should you pick?
  15. 18:23Raids: too early to say

FAQ

Is Shadow Priest or Warlock better in WoW Forever?

Neither is better for everyone. Shadow Priest is better for versatility, self-sustain and fast dungeon queues as a healer. Warlock is better for maximum damage, stronger crowd control and a demon companion.

Can a Shadow Priest heal dungeons in WoW Forever?

Yes. A Shadow Priest can heal dungeons while leveling. It takes a bit more mana management around Spirit Tap.

Which class levels faster in WoW Forever, Shadow Priest or Warlock?

About the same. Priests rarely stop for mana thanks to Spirit Tap; Warlocks use Life Tap but sometimes eat.

Which class makes more gold in WoW Forever?

Both farm well. Choose professions and farming spots that play to your class's strengths.

Ryan's note: Based on my own gameplay at level 34, November 2026. Things may change after tuning passes and at level 60.

Full transcript

Show the transcript of "Shadow priest or Warlock in WoW Forever?"

0:00Shadow Priest or Warlock?

Man, the snow in Alterac Mountains looks good. So anyway, if you're anything like me, you might have been wondering, okay, should I play a Shadow Priest or a Warlock in World of Warcraft Forever? And I'm not here to give you a 100% definitive answer because everybody's choices are different, but I'm gonna give you my perspective of what I think. I've played Warlock over the entirety of Classic back in 2019, and I've played a Warlock back in TBC as well, and I've also tried a Warlock in World of Warcraft Forever for the first 15 levels only, but then I deleted her.

0:33What to compare: solo, elites, gold, PvP

So here's the thing that we should start with. If you're considering a Shadow Priest versus Warlock, you're thinking about doing damage. And the way I like to look at my characters is, what else can I do besides, okay, just do damage, right? Can I play solo efficiently? Is it gonna be difficult for me to solo elite quests maybe? Because I don't always want to find a group, you know? And I like to challenge myself as well. Is it gonna be feasible for me to farm gold? Is it gonna be feasible for me to do PvP? All this sort of thing, right? And will I have to spend an extraordinary amount of time on some arbitrary stuff that I don't want to do? You know, like lockpicking, for example, for rogues.

1:18Rotation: Shadow Priest vs Affliction Warlock

And in terms of Shadow Priests and Warlocks, I think there's very similar in number one, the first talent spec of the Warlock, which is the Affliction. So playing Shadow Priest is kind of like playing an Affliction Warlock, but to a certain extent, you're a little bit weaker. I don't know how it's gonna be at the end of, you know, at the end game. So like when you hit level 60 or 50, something like that, whenever we have access to more talents, more gear, all that sort of thing. But as of right now, at level 34, I'm not a Shadow Priest anymore, even. I respect the discipline. It's a lot more fun than Shadow. I feel like the Shadow Priest is better for what I'm doing. So your typical rotation as a Warlock is okay. You cast your Corruption, which is a Shadow Word: Pain. You cast your Curse of Agony, boom, Devouring Plague. You might hit up another dot situation. You might use, you might send your pet to attack and wand it down or drain life it down. So what you're essentially doing is just casting dots, waiting for the dots to tick and healing yourself in the meantime with drain life or something. Maybe drain soul, right? As a Priest, what's your rotation? Shadow Word: Pain, Holy Fire for me right now, Devouring Plague, and Penance or just casting Renew on myself. I'm not even healing myself at all because I do have a shield and I need to spend time on healing myself. So what is the difference? Really the flavor, at least in my eyes, right? So that's kind of a tie over here.

2:50Versatility and self-healing

Now when it comes to versatility, Warlocks don't have the versatility of Priest. Let's not kid ourselves. They bring a whole different type of versatility, but as a Priest, I can absolutely play as a DPS talent build. I did heal a lot in Shadow as I was leveling and I can do content as a group. I can solo stuff in the open world. I can solo hard stuff in the open world as well because Shadow has access to all the healing, most of the healing spells I think. You don't have access to Penance, of course, and like Holy Nova, but if you're Shadow, you're absolutely healing yourself all day, right? With Spirit Tap, you have Renews, you have shields, you have shields, it's all good. So it feels a lot more versatile and a lot more sustainable, right? You do not have Life Tap, but you have Spirit Tap. You do not have Drain Life, you have Renew. So in terms of versatility of the toolkit, well, the Priest clearly wins in my opinion. Warlocks can summon people for sure, but your versatility is for other people in the most part. You can summon people, you can give them health stones, you can give them soul stones so they can resurrect if they die, and that's cool, right? You have better CC, that's for sure. You have Spamable Fear, and if you're playing within Succubus, you do have a Charm on Humanoids, which is extremely useful, especially in PvP, right? But that's besides the real point. The real point is the versatility out in the open because we're mostly playing PvE. And let's not kid ourselves. When I think, when most people think of versatility of the class, they think versatility in terms of their own gameplay, not necessarily only for other people, right? And I can heal myself, I can heal other people. As a Warlock, I can use my own health stone, maybe I can soul stone myself if needed, but that's really about it. I have Drain Life, that's where it ends. And Curse, I forgot the name from Affliction 3.

4:39Destruction Warlock and Shadow Bolt

However, the Warlock has an access to another skilled talent tree, so the Destruction. I think it's the most unique one that has been a lot more fleshed out with World of Warcraft Forever. It looks really cool on paper, but I feel like it's honestly just a mage. It's just a mage that uses different flavor of magic. They use Shadow Magic and Fire Magic. It's cool, it's powerful, you're gonna be doing a lot of damage for sure, but there's just essentially a lot of standing and casting. And as a Shadow Priest, you have the mobility. You do not have your big, spammable Shadow Bolt, unfortunately, so maybe if that's your thing, if you wanna spam big numbers on your enemy, well, Shadow Bolt is gonna be probably your thing. Or if not Shadow Bolt, then this Incinerate thing, the new spammable spell, right?

5:31Executes: Shadowburn vs Shadow Word: Death

We both do have Executes, so Warlocks have Shadowburn, and Priests have Shadow Word: Death, in all specializations, by the way. So I think, in my opinion, another point to the Priest.

5:44Making gold

Making Gold. Now, I'm only level 34 in World of Warcraft Forever right now, but as a Warlock, I did make thousands of Gold in World of Warcraft Classic, and I don't feel like I've honestly had any problem making Gold on any character, even a Warrior. It's just a matter of figuring out what your character is good at, and then playing to that character's strength. Shadow Priest is probably gonna be good at farming a lot of different monsters that die quick, right? Because you have your Dots, you can just... I showed it in my other video. You can pull entire camps of monsters and don't even care about it. Warlock can do exactly the same thing, and that's what I was doing as well. So I feel like both can absolutely farm a lot of Gold.

6:25Dungeons and finding a group

Raid-wise. Maybe dungeon-wise. Raid-wise, we don't really know about raids yet. About dungeon-wise. Have you noticed, when you press Looking for Group? Let's search for a group over here. For... anything, really. How many groups are full of DPS? They even have tanks. And how many groups have a healer waiting in the group? Yeah. That's going to limit your gameplay, bro. Like, if you do like group content and doing dungeons, playing Warlock carries an inherent disadvantage, unfortunately, because most people do play DPS builds in this game. And as a Shadow Priest, you can play a DPS build outside in the open world, and you can absolutely heal until level 60, for sure, as a Shadow. You just have to adapt your gameplay specifically to playing Shadow. It's a little bit more intricate with making sure... or trying to make sure that Spirit Tap procs here and there, so you don't run out of mana. But you should be good. And I did that. I played Hardcore WoW as a Shadow Priest, and it was giga fun, even healing. And people had no problem with me healing as Shadow, by the way, in... in hardcore. So in World of Warcraft Forever, again, those things carry over. Like, we've had improvements to the classes, they're a bit different, but the same thing carries over. The Priest is going to have an inherent advantage in terms of finding group content. You can queue as a healer, and honestly, healing in a dungeon, right now, as of this level, and I don't expect it to change much at all. Boils down to casting a shield on your tank, pre-casting it, waiting for it to pop off, sorry, to drop, rather. Then maybe casting a Penance, giving him a Renew, and maybe renewing the shield. And that's... that's a big pull already. You're golden. In the meantime, you're wanding... I always cast my Shadow Word: Pain on everything. So I'm still actively doing DPS as a healer, actually. And that's... that's actually another video that I'll probably end up making as well, how to, like, actually heal as a Priest, because you don't stand there and just wait to cast heals. That's... that's not the Priest gameplay. You are supposed to be actively wanding your enemies, dotting them whenever you have surplus mana. You can use Penance to damage them. You can use Shadow Word: Death to trigger your Spirit Tap. You can absolutely do a lot of things. As a Warlock, you do not have that. You cannot heal your friends. You cannot... sorry. You cannot heal as a healer at all. So you cannot be as... like, Shadow Priest, hey, I'm really a DPS build, but I'm gonna heal as a healer. Sort of situation, you know? So, again, I think that's a minus for Warlocks.

8:58Questing speed and mana

So maybe let's talk about, um, Questing. I feel like, overall, both of these complete quests usually give or take at the same time. Because you don't sit as a Priest. You can see me farming here. Oh, farming is a big word over here. Not a lot of spawns. But, like, I'm killing things. I haven't sat down once to regen mana, nothing. As a Warlock, you do not sit down to regen mana, but because you have Life Tap, but sometimes you might have to eat, if you do not drain a knife life from the monster. So that's gonna essentially slow you down, and you do kill faster, but if you're slowed down every now and then, overall, on average, your healing speed is probably gonna be similar to a Shadow Priest, for sure. Especially a Shadow Priest that has proper guild build for it, because whenever I was playing Shadow Priest here, I did not gear for all Shadow damage. I geared for healing and spell power overall. If you especially gear for, have maybe a separate gear set, just for dealing Shadow damage, you're gonna be golden. You have your Mind Flay, right here. And it's very early on, too. That actually gives you another button to press. It doesn't cost a lot of mana. It's a fantastic skill because it slows monsters down, so you do not need to cast a Curse of Exhaustion or something like that to slow your enemy additionally to whatever you're already doing, whenever it's running away from you. You're just casting your Mind Flay and slow down baseline. Yeah. I was hoping to cast Holy Fire on this guy, but it just, he just didn't want us to stay in place. I think, overall, they both quest the same speed.

10:29First 100 gold and skinning turtles

Getting 100 gold, I'm right now not even at 20. I've spent a lot on my skills because I wanted to get as many skills as possible. Getting 100 gold on both Priest and Warlock seemed like an easy task, honestly, but I feel like that boils down mostly to the proper choice of professions, the proper farming spot, and this sort of thing rather than the class itself. A lot of people would say that Mages farm the fastest, but we don't really know that yet because apparently AoE farming has been nerfed, but you don't care about that as a Priest or a Warlock that much, so there you go. Here's the hint. This is a good spot if you hear a skinning to farm early gold. There are a lot of Turtles here, and as a Warlock, and a Warlock and a Shadow Priest actually, you can just run around this coast, dot every turtle around, until they start running away from you. Just destroy them and then skin them. That's a lot of gold. That's how I made most of my gold for all of my mounts in World of Warcraft Classic, and I'll probably do the same for World of Warcraft Forever. I just don't have skinning because this time I decided to go over hard the route and I get myself tailoring.

11:39Gear competition

In terms of gear, a lot more people play Warlocks. You're going to have a lot more competition for your gear. So that's also something to consider. If your goal is to gear up the raid-ready sort of thing, well, you're going to have a lot more competition. I would consider this when making a character. I was actually considering this when making the Priest as well. Like, I didn't want to make a character that suddenly like a hundred million people play, because I'm going to have trouble finding... Like, nobody wants to have a group in a dungeon that consists of three Warlocks. Most Warlocks don't know how to play a Warlock, so let's start with that. They cast Corruption, they end up casting all of their dots, and by the time all of their dots even start doing damage, the monster should be there already anyway, so you end up doing no damage. That's a very common thing, by the way.

12:23Demonology and pets

So there's one thing that we haven't considered yet is the demon. The demon, the demonology tree. It's a very cool tree, and it looks even more fun in World of Warcraft Forever. So Warlock has something that no other character has, and actually an interesting pet. I feel like hunter pets are kind of okay. They're not really that interesting. I mean, you can have a cool lion, right? But... Lion versus Incubus, or Succubus? Oh, I think I'm going with the Succubus, right? You just feel cooler, have a demon next to you. And you have a whole tree dedicated to them, and it's very fun. But I feel like it's going to be more fun, or the most fun, only when you're, like, level 60. When you get all the Capstone talents and you're able to have a demon sacrificed and have one out anyway, that sort of thing. Controlling your demons is a whole different gameplay too, and it requires... If you're a neutered Warlock class, you're not going to be good at controlling your demons, by the way. Like, the higher level gameplay of a Warlock involves so much intricacies. In terms of demon placement, behavior, casting spells, having all the proper macros for casting the demon spells, being able to fell them another pet based on the situation. It's a lot more than just sending it to attack, or attack for you, you know? That's like the super surface level of playing a Warlock, actually. So, if you do not want to manage another unit, well, Warlock already loses some points, in your opinion. At least that should be the case. Priest doesn't have that problem. All your trees are baked into just your character, and that's cool. Which, you know, there's also another side to the coin. I'm trying to consider all sides of every argument. That it can, for example, feel a little bit lonely. You know, it's just you out there. I have my pet parrot, that's cool. But like, if it's just you out there, braving the entire world, if you're not that type of guy, you know, a pet is gonna make it feel like you have a companion with you, which is cool. That's... some people like that, some people consider that, you know?

14:31PvP and battlegrounds

PvP wise, Shadow Priest and Affliction Warlocks are the absolute scourge of PvP, both of them. And I don't think this is gonna change at all. I feel like it's even gonna be better for priests right now, because all priests have access to Shadow Word: Death. And I have right now 1600 health. If I crit with Shadow Word: Death, I can take out half of my own life, give or take. And God forbid, you're in Shadowform, you crit with Shadow Word: Death. That's gonna almost take somebody out immediately. Your damage is just nuts, right? I feel like Warlocks do not have access to this sort of situation. Maybe, maybe, maybe with Shadowburns, who knows. But I just don't feel like it's really the case, at least with Affliction builds. Because if we're comparing Shadow Priest to Warlock, we really should be comparing just Affliction versus Shadow Priest, right? I think my verdict for Battlegrounds would still be the Shadow Priest, simply because you're able to change the tide of the fight a lot more. And I feel like that's what's important in PvP, being able to influence the fight. You can absolutely do this by shielding your friends, and you can still do damage in the meantime. And as a Warlock, you can fear your opponents, but I can do the same with the priests. I just need to unfortunately get a little bit closer. But other than that, your job is to put a lot of pressure on your enemies by dotting everybody up on the opponent team. And it's really it, but it's also a lot to do as well. So you're going to be casting Corruption, Agony, Tap, Corruption, Agony, Tap, Corruption, Agony, Tap, Corruption, Agony, Tap, and just putting the baseline level of pressure on the entirety of the enemy team. That is actually, I'm looking for a good word, but not prices, but really important. That's what I'm trying to say. A good Warlock managing the pressure on the entire group is really good to have on your team. Because it's just a massive pressure on the enemy killer's team. So they can't really keep up, but they can't really heal like five targets in the front. They have to heal everybody because everybody's just freaking melting, right? And if you're casting Rack, this new thing that makes your dots tick faster, you're going to be putting pressure on like the backline of your opponent's team and just like melting the guy in the front as well. So Warlock is fantastic. But again, I feel like being able to help out your team outside of also doing a lot of damage wins.

17:02Verdict: which class should you pick?

So it's priest favor again. That's my opinion. You're free to experiment with both classes yourself. Unfortunately, we kind of like really, truly experiment until we make both the classes until level 60. But you can't get a kind of a grasp on it like when you're like level 25 at least, you know? Just queue up a battleground and see how you play, see how you like it or not, you know? I have a level 19 Rogue specifically for that because I wanted to see how Rogues play now. And it's still not my thing, unfortunately. Even though I know Rogues are strong, it's just not for me. And that's really the point of this video to help you kind of ask yourself the right questions and give yourself the right answers based on what is your goal in the game and how you like playing a game because there is really no one universal answer like, okay, Shadow Priest is 100% always better. No, there's no answer like that. There's no and there's no answer like, okay, the Athletic Spring Warlock is always going to be better. If your goal is to play a lot of group content and not wait in queues, well, Priest, there we go. If your goal is to do crazy damage and just see people melt and that's what tickles your fancy, absolutely play the Warlock because Shadow Priest can do that, but Warlocks have a lot more tools for this. So it's like Shadow Priest plus something, you know? And that's really about it.

18:23Raids: too early to say

That's really about it. I don't want to talk about raiding because we don't really know what raiding is going to look like. I can only talk from like World of Warcraft Classics perspective and World of Warcraft Forever is probably going to be a lot different, especially that all the raiding mechanics are different and debuff limits are gone and curses work differently and all that sort of thing. So we'll see when we get there and I'll see you guys in the next video. I have a whole bunch of videos on the Priest if you're a Priest player. So go ahead and watch that and I'll see you soon.

More WoW Forever Priest guides

Is Priest Good for New Players in WoW Forever? 3:03

Is Priest Good for New Players in WoW Forever?

Is Priest a good class for new players in World of Warcraft: Forever (WoW Forever)? Yes. Priest is one of the most new-player-friendly classes in WoW Forever: it deals a surprising amount of damage while leveling, has huge self-survivability, almost no downtime, and can heal dungeons without being "just a healer". In this video Ryan Geldun explains why, from Shadow Word: Pain at level 4 and Power Word: Shield at level 6 to wands and dungeon healing.

Early Game Priest Guide for WoW Forever (Levels 1-20) 9:23

Early Game Priest Guide for WoW Forever (Levels 1-20)

How do you level a Priest early in World of Warcraft: Forever (WoW Forever)? Go Shadow, get a wand at level 5, stack Spirit, Intellect and Stamina with +healing and +spell damage gear, and use Shadow Word: Pain plus wand as your rotation. In this video Ryan Geldun shows his own Priest from level 1 to 20 in WoW Forever: stats, talents, wands, consumables, Tailoring and dungeon gear, recorded in November 2026.

How to AoE Level a Priest in WoW Forever 7:07

How to AoE Level a Priest in WoW Forever

Can a Priest AoE level in World of Warcraft: Forever (WoW Forever)? Yes, just not with AoE spells. In this video Ryan Geldun farms 4-5 mobs at a time as a level 26 Shadow Priest in the Wetlands: DoT everything, Psychic Scream the pack, kill one mob fast for Spirit Tap and let the rest die to DoTs and wand. Recorded in November 2026.

See all 8 Priest guides →